Compare in more detail
Sildenafil or tadalafil? Both are PDE5 inhibitors that support erections during sexual stimulation. The practical difference is duration. In one study of tadalafil 20 mg, about 59% of attempts were successful at 36 hours versus 28% with placebo. In a placebo-controlled sildenafil study, 74% of men reported improved erections versus 16% with placebo.
Tablet or dissolving? Standard tablets are swallowed. Dissolving tablets (ODT) and troches dissolve in the mouth, which some people find easier. How they perform has been studied less than standard tablets.
One medicine or a combination? Single medicines are the usual starting point and make side effects easier to attribute. Combination products add a second ingredient, such as Pycnogenol or a second PDE5 inhibitor, and are sometimes discussed after an incomplete response.
What is established. The effects of sildenafil, tadalafil and vardenafil are well established in trials of standard products. Compounded combinations and dissolving formats were not themselves studied in those trials.
Safety for all options. None of these can be used with nitrate medicines. Seek emergency care for an erection lasting more than 4 hours or sudden vision or hearing loss.